New York Theme Catering

New York Theme Catering

New York City isn’t just a location — it’s an energy, a mood, and a cultural mosaic. When translated into event design, this means rich culinary diversity, urban-chic aesthetics, and layered storytelling. At Gotham Catering and Events, our approach to New York theme catering captures more than just iconic food. We curate immersive, upscale experiences where every element — from menu to mood — channels the city's unmistakable character.

Whether you're planning a corporate launch in Midtown, a rooftop wedding in Brooklyn, or a private dinner in a historic brownstone, NYC's spirit can anchor the entire vision. And no two events are the same. That’s the magic of working with a boutique team that builds each concept from scratch — just like the city itself, we evolve, adapt, and surprise.

New York Theme Catering Menu

Luxury NYC Culinary Experience for Corporate & Social Events

Pricing

$34.95 per guest – One Entrée
$39.95 per guest – Two Entrées
$44.95 per guest – Three Entrées
Includes one starter, two sides, one salad, artisan bread, cookies, sliced fruit, and condiments.

Starters

• Mini Everything Bagel Bites with Whipped Cream Cheese Trio
• Soft Pretzel Bites with Spicy Deli Mustard and Warm Beer Cheese Fondue
• Chopped New York Caesar with Garlic Croutons and Shaved Parmesan
• Times Square Bruschetta Bar – Tomato Basil, Roasted Red Pepper, Mushroom Tapenade
• NYC Street Cart Falafel Bites with Tahini and Cucumber Yogurt Sauce

Entrées

• NYC-Style Hot Dog Experience with Artisan Toppings
• Mini Reuben Sliders with Pastrami, Swiss, and Sauerkraut on Rye
• Brooklyn Thin-Crust Pizza Station – Pepperoni, Margherita, and Seasonal Veggie
• NYC Deli Board – Turkey, Pastrami, Roast Beef, Tuna Salad, and Gourmet Veggie Wraps
• Bronx Italian Sausage & Sweet Peppers with Garlic Knots
• Queens Korean BBQ Chicken with Sesame Scallion Finish
• Manhattan Smoked Salmon & Whitefish Platter (Premium Upgrade)
• Vegan NYC Street Bowl with Roasted Market Vegetables, Quinoa, and Lemon Tahini

Signature Sides

• Manhattan Deli Potato Salad
• Sweet Corn on the Cob with Herb Butter
• NYC Pizzeria Garlic Knots
• Red Hook Roasted Seasonal Vegetables
• Coney Island Curly Fries
• Long Island Roasted Sweet Potatoes
• Chinatown Wok-Seared Vegetables
• Lower East Side Latkes with Sour Cream and Apple Compote

Salads

• Union Square Market Greens with Lemon Vinaigrette
• Broadway Chopped Salad with Chickpeas, Peppers, Cucumbers, and Olives
• SoHo Caprese with Fresh Mozzarella, Grape Tomatoes, Basil, and Aged Balsamic
• Classic NY Deli Coleslaw

Artisan Breads

• New York–Style Rolls and Brioche Slider Buns
• Pretzel Rolls
• Warm Garlic Knots
• Kosher Pickle Spears

Desserts

• Classic New York Cheesecake Bites
• Black & White Cookies
• Brooklyn Chocolate Brownies
• Mini Cannoli with Chocolate Chip Ricotta Filling
• NYC Bakery Cookie Collection

Beverages

$5.95 per guest

• Freshly Brewed Iced Tea
• Lemonade 

Optional Enhancements

• NYC-inspired event décor and branded signage
• Hot pretzel & knish stations
• Interactive cheesecake tower display
• Premium beverage stations and bar upgrades

Customization & Event Notes

• Vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free, and allergy-friendly menus available
• Custom menu development for branded and experiential events
• Ideal for corporate activations, client events, and luxury celebrations
• Minimum order: 25 guests

Why NYC-Themed Catering Resonates for Events

New York is universally recognizable and endlessly reinterpretable. Its culinary traditions range from bagel carts to fine dining, and its boroughs each hold distinct identities. That’s what makes an NYC theme so versatile — it works equally well for a corporate holiday party, a wedding celebration, or a fundraising gala. The vibe can swing from playful to sophisticated, depending on your vision. In inclusive and expressive celebrations, such as pride parties or equality-focused events, NYC’s diverse backdrop becomes even more essential. The energy of the city reflects individuality and community — a dynamic we often bring to life in our LGBTQ-themed catering experiences.

At Gotham, we design menus that echo the neighborhoods of New York while maintaining our upscale standards. A smoky, artfully plated brisket nods to Brooklyn’s BBQ culture. Spiced cornbread with jalapeño honey? A tribute to street food with a refined twist. These aren’t just dishes — they’re stories on a plate. Take our Southwest BBQ menu, for example — it’s hearty and bold, perfect for bringing a Williamsburg warehouse party or Meatpacking District rooftop gathering to life. For a more internationally driven flavor profile, our Brazilian BBQ buffet brings vibrant color and flair to summer soirées and cultural events.

Flavors of the World, NYC Style

New York has always been a meeting point of cultures, and this global fusion shows up in our kitchen. We celebrate that with curated menus that are deeply rooted in culinary traditions yet shaped by contemporary NYC tastes. Our Asian Fusion catering merges sleek presentation with bold flavor — think dim sum passed hors d’oeuvres and sushi sliders under city lights. For South American flair, our Brazilian catering takes an elegant, buffet-style approach to churrasco, perfect for gala-style events or upscale fundraisers. It’s experiential and flavorful, and it pairs perfectly with rooftop settings or venues that lean into NYC’s cosmopolitan roots.

What’s more New York than the smell of pretzels and popcorn from a Central Park vendor? We often bring that nostalgia to life with live stations and interactive carts that elevate these classics into gourmet moments. Our pretzel machine setup is a guest favorite at both weddings and brand activations. It's familiar, but with a twist — soft-baked, artisan-style, served with artisanal dips.

Paired with a popcorn machine popping truffle or cheddar blends on-site, these elements add both sensory depth and movement to your event layout. And of course, for any event aiming to evoke classic NYC street eats, our hot dog catering carts bring authenticity with just the right amount of whimsy.

Bringing the Outdoors In with NYC Picnic Vibes

Central Park picnics and East River cookouts are quintessential New York warm-weather traditions. But even indoor venues can tap into that breezy charm. Our picnic theme catering creates relaxed, open-air aesthetics, whether inside loft spaces or under summer tents.

With gingham runners, wildflower arrangements, and classic lemonade cocktails, we recreate the city’s seasonal joy — refined for your guests. Our custom BBQ stations serve slow-grilled favorites with an elevated twist, tying together the laid-back flavor of a New York picnic with boutique execution. The soul of NYC is its global neighborhoods — each corner offering a different accent, a different spice, a different story. Our Italian Feast captures the spirit of Little Italy with rustic pastas and antipasti boards built for sharing. For a Mediterranean take, our Greek-themed catering leans into olive oils, fresh herbs, and fire-grilled meats that reflect the vibrancy of Astoria’s Greek enclaves.

French cuisine has its place too — especially in soirées that require a softer, more romantic feel. With our French Connection offering, you’ll see delicate pastries, rich sauces, and elegant presentations that transport your guests straight from Manhattan to Montmartre.

Immersive Event Themes That Go Beyond the Menu

Food is only part of the experience. For a truly immersive New York-themed event, Gotham Catering and Events weaves together storytelling, design, and flavor to build cohesive worlds. We’ve brought film noir to life with our Godfather-inspired menu and aesthetic, blending Italian-American cuisine with moody lighting and classic soundtrack cues. These are more than meals — they’re curated experiences for guests who expect something beyond traditional catering.

We’ve also reimagined Chinatown’s hustle and bustle with our China Express concept, which merges dim sum-style service with vivid red and gold design elements. Whether inspired by movies, boroughs, or historic NYC subcultures, our themed executions stay rooted in both authenticity and upscale production value. Some events call for lighthearted fun. Gotham's carnival-themed events combine color, motion, and flavor — ideal for corporate family days, school fundraisers, or community-centric occasions. Our carnival theme catering includes interactive stations like cotton candy spins, funnel cakes with powdered sugar snow, and old-school beverage carts — all refined with a boutique touch.

Looking for something a little more coastal? We recreate summer in Rockaway with our Day at the Beach BBQ experience — perfect for venues near the Hudson, rooftop lounges, or even indoor spaces transformed with driftwood, soft lighting, and salt-air-inspired menu choices.

Begin Your NYC-Themed Celebration

True luxury comes from not having to worry about the details. Gotham doesn’t just deliver food — we create seamless experiences that stretch from the first conversation to the final guest departure. We start with your event's purpose, then match that vision with a menu, aesthetic, and flow that fits the brand, the mood, and the moment. For themed events, this level of integration is essential. Every floral choice, tray pass, or server uniform contributes to the atmosphere. Our planning team handles rentals, layout, staff coordination, and food production with the precision required for high-stakes, high-style gatherings. It's a full-circle experience, designed to let you be a guest at your own event.

Whether you're envisioning a rooftop soirée with signature cocktails or a full-scale immersive gala inspired by the five boroughs, Gotham Catering and Events is your partner in bringing it to life. Our deep understanding of New York’s cultural richness — paired with our commitment to bespoke service — means no detail goes overlooked. From our take on Greek fusion menus to creative installations pulled straight from NYC’s streets, we blend substance with style. Ready to explore your own New York-themed event? Let’s create something unforgettable.